Han Kun Law Firm - Research on Recognizability of Product Appearance Design
Case Details
Firm Overview Han Kun Law Firm is one of China's leading comprehensive law firms, specializing in complex commercial transactions and dispute resolution both domestically and internationally. As a leading legal firm in China's legal industry, Han Kun boasts a team of experienced and highly qualified lawyers with extensive practical experience. The firm has long provided legal services to clients across both domestic and international markets, particularly excelling in handling cross-border transactions and complex commercial disputes. Han Kun offers high-quality legal services across various sectors, including technology, finance, and intellectual property, empowering clients to navigate legal challenges on a global scale. Research Background Apple is currently involved in a legal case concerning the similarity between the appearance design of a particular smartphone and an existing design patent. The central issue in this dispute centers on whether consumers can identify significant differences between the smartphone's appearance and the relevant patented designs. To provide robust evidence for the trial, Apple has decided to conduct a third-party market research study to understand consumer recognition of the phone's appearance design, thereby assisting the court in determining whether infringement has occurred. In this regard, Han Kun Law Firm commissioned CEIDEA Research to carry out market research, collecting data on consumers' recognition of the phone's appearance design, which will serve as key evidence in the case.
Research scope
In May 2020, CEIDEA Research was commissioned by Han Kun Law Firm to conduct an in-depth investigation into consumers' recognition of the appearance design of a particular iPhone developed by Apple. The primary objective of this study was to assess whether consumers can accurately distinguish the appearance of this phone from existing design patents in everyday usage. Specific research components included: 1) Consumers' awareness of mobile phone appearance designs and their ability to differentiate between brands and models; 2) Consumers' perceptions regarding the similarities and differences between the iPhone and the relevant patented designs; 3) Consumers' evaluations of the uniqueness and market recognition of the phone's appearance; 4) Whether consumers can clearly identify the product's origin based on its visual features. These data will provide CEIDEA Research with first-hand insights into consumer perception, enabling Apple to effectively support its claims during litigation. Expected Outcomes Through this research, Han Kun Law Firm will obtain detailed data on consumers' recognition of the phone's appearance design, providing critical evidence for the trial. The findings will help the court understand consumers' intuitive experiences in daily use and clarify whether consumers are likely to confuse the phone with the relevant patented designs. Ultimately, CEIDEA Research's report will deliver legally relevant consumer feedback, supporting the court in making more precise determinations regarding potential patent infringement, and providing strong legal arguments for Apple during the trial proceedings.
Scan to add our research consultant